Beulah was a suspected murderess who soon after Belva gaertner was arrested for murder. At 23, Kentucky-native Annan was on her second marriage. Nonetheless, her husband Albert Annan stood by her side and frantically used his life savings to fund her defense. Belva Gaertner, once known as the "Queen of Chicago's cabarets,"was a 38 year old cabaret singer, she had been divorced twice. 1924 to be exact. She'd repeatedly rejected Bob Fosse's pleas to adapt it. Court proceedings were whirling bouts of confusion for the foreigner at the center of the story. women were called flappers, for their short provocative skirts and actions. Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner, Social Opposites 1202 Words | 5 Pages. In the Roaring 20s. On the Broadway stage and on the big screen, Roxie Hart and Velma Kelly came alive through catchy tunes and sexy dance numbers. She hoped this dark comedy would highlight how appearances and sex appeal had become too important in the justice system. She'd be found at her apartment. Annan's story proved to be more the stuff of sensational headlines. 281-955-9721 Kasib Romine. They aren't worth it, because there are always plenty more. Law was “found shot to death at 1:30 A.M. in a Sedan at 50th St. and Forrestville Ave., a .32 cal.… But while the fictional femme fatale slaughtered her sister and cheating husband, her real-life inspiration allegedly shot her married lover. However, she soon tired of her mechanic husband and began taking up with a hot number named Harry Kalstedt. 281-237-1773 Dirward Abalos. The Bob Fosse masterpiece we know and love today as Chicago the musical actually started with two real women and two real murdered men. Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure began 32 years ago this week, Thank Kermit that Muppet Treasure Island let Tim Curry be as wacky as his Muppet co-stars, 'Willy's Wonderland' director sees his Evil Dead send-up as the next great horror entry in the Nic Cage 'genre', Recap: Resident Alien's women are straight-up running this show in Episode 4, Constantine getting younger in new dark reboot from Bad Robot, HBO Max, Netflix lands Tim Burton's 'Wednesday Addams' project with 8-episode live action series, The worlds of Richard Donner's Superman & Tim Burton's Batman getting the comic book treatment, Superman & Lois: Critics say The CW series is family drama meets a bit of Snyder-esque darkness, Ultramega: Humans mutate into killer kaiju in Skybound/Image's wild new sci-fi series, How Resident Alien transformed from a Dark Horse comic into a SYFY original series, From True Blood to Deathstroke, Joe Manganiello is living the dream, Who Won the Week: Cyberpunk 2077's Johnny Silverhand vs. Archenemy's Max Fist, Netflix's La Revolution and why we need more period horror pieces, 35 thoughts we had while watching the LEGO Star Wars Holiday Special, Share The real story behind Chicago's Merry Murderesses, Roxie Hart and Velma Kelly on Facebook, Share The real story behind Chicago's Merry Murderesses, Roxie Hart and Velma Kelly on Twitter, Share The real story behind Chicago's Merry Murderesses, Roxie Hart and Velma Kelly on Reddit. Nonetheless, these women's legend lives on, not only through Chicago's smirking celebration of drink, sex, murder, and all that jazz but also through homicide trials that lean hard on how a woman presents herself instead of on the facts of the case. 281-955-0682 Before the names were changed to protect the not-so-innocent, Roxie Hart and Velma Kelly were known as Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner. Your email address will not be published. The loyal husband that stood by her through infidelity and murder charges was ruthlessly dumped. Walter was just a kid — 29 and I'm 38. She confessed to Chicago Tribune journalist Maurine Dallas Watkins, "No woman can love a man enough to kill him. But who were these murderesses, really? Or 29. At the time of the murder, Belva had already been something of a media sensation because of her messy divorce from millionaire William Gaertner. Then, as he lay dying, Annan put a record of a jaunty foxtrot called "Hula Lou." After four months in jail awaiting trial, each was found not guilty. Gaertner, a cabaret singer, likewise was found Not Guilty for the murder of Walter Law who was found dead in Gaertner's abandoned car. 281-237-3560 Emlynn Leamer. May 6, 2015 - Belva+Gaertner+Photo | Maureen Dallas Watkins, Reporter for the Chicago Tribune ... 1924—Beulah Annan & Belva Gaertner. Of Annan, this groundbreaking reporter wrote, "They say she's the prettiest woman ever accused of murder in Chicago — young, slender, with bobbed auburn hair; wide-set, appealing blue eyes; up-tilted nose; translucent skin, faintly, very faintly, rouged, an ingenuous smile; refined features, intelligent expression—an 'awfully nice girl' and more than usually pretty.". Belva Gaertner (L) and Beulah Annan (R) The true story of the accused but acquitted Chicago beauties who inspired musical legends Roxie Hart and Velma Kelly. Newspaper articles compiled and posted on Chicagology.com. It was she who transformed Annan, Gaertner, their victims, husbands, lawyers, peers, and reporters into characters like Roxie Hart, Velma Kelly, Billy Flynn, Mary Sunshine, and Go-To-Hell Kitty. Saved by Hayley Ritz. Watkins based her show on her experiences working for The Chicago Tribune in 1924, covering the trials of Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner. We will now go into the night of her incident. It's speculated she faked a pregnancy to save her own skin. The press and the public ate up the gossip, the details on dresses, and the sob stories about bad men, booze, and devilish jazz. At the time, Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner, the inspirations for the musical Chicago, were there awaiting trial. which extended far beyond Watkins' coverage. Get on your glad rags and pour the bathtub gin, because we're looking back to the Merry Murderesses that inspired Chicago. Beulah Annan, left, and Belva Gaertner, both on trial for murder in 1924. Following her husband's death in 1948, she moved to California where she lived with her sister, Malinda Kraushaar, until her passing. Watkins used Gaertner's story as part of the inspiration for her play Chicago; Roxie Hart, the lead character in Chicago, is a former entertainer who blames her crime on jazz, liquor and guns. Dressed to kill, Gaertner even sat in … The play “Chicago” premiered in 1926 and was based on the unrelated stories of Gaertner and Beulah Annan, another woman acquitted of murder in the Windy City in 1924. Her story inspired Maurine Dallas Watkins's play Chicago in 1926. But what became of the real Roxie and Velma? Since 1975, Chicago has sung of the glamorous murderesses of the Jazz Age. As she felt the pair were guilty and likely lying through their teeth, she had mixed feelings on that. Belva Gaertner a cabaret dancer living in Chicago in the 1920’s, was arrested for the murder of Walter Law, whom she was rumored to have an extramarital affair with, on March 12 of 1924. 281-237-8456 – Violet Rebecca Jubane, Roxie Hart Character Research – Halle'Maia Dumetz. ", Meanwhile, Gaertner was peddling herself as a victim of the evil jazz scene. ", Over six months on this beat, Watkins made a name for herself by recounting every detail of these cases, the accused stories — even as they changed — and the way they looked. Belva+Gaertner+Photo | Maureen Dallas Watkins, Reporter for the Chicago Tribune. Before the names were changed to protect the not-so-innocent, Roxie Hart and Velma Kelly were known as Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner. Belle Brown Overbeck Gaertner A.K.A. This paved the way for her self-defense argument—even though Kalstedt was putting on his hat and coat when he was shot in the back. 281-955-7934 Dorelia Hollyfield. Ripped from the Headlines by Harold Schechter, Published by Little A, New York, 2020. 281-237-3065 Clodomiro Howes. Her estate did not, and so Fosse's Chicago hit Broadway in 1975. “No sweetheart is worth killing,” (121) so started Belva Gaertner with the (ill-)famed utterance, and continued, “─especially when you have had a … As in Chicago, this confessed murderess claimed, "We Both Reached For The Gun." It didn't seem to matter. Prosecutors argued the same motive to both: vengeance on the lover who would leave them. Annan, Gaertner, and others took advantage of this attention to appearance, which extended far beyond Watkins' coverage. Belva shot her lover in the midst of a very drunken spat about who was the better shot. One more thing. Chicago takes more liberties with her story. Music: "Hula Lou" - 1923 recording by Isabelle Patricola, 1924—Beulah Annan & Belva Gaertner Back to Notorious Chicago Chicago Tribunereporter Maurine Dallas Watkins (July 27, 1896 – August 10, 1969) covered these two murder cases in order to provide a “woman’s angle.” She left the Tribune after only six months and made millions on a play she wrote based on these two cases. Newspaper articles compiled and posted on Chicagology.com. Annan was accused of murdering her sweetheart Harry Kalstedt on April 4, 1924. The first part of the book focuses largely on the crimes, trials, and eventual acquittals of Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner, the “Most Beautiful Girl” and the “Most Stylish Girl” on Murders’ Row, respectively. Gaertner was not at the scene. May 6, 2015 - Belva+Gaertner+Photo | Maureen Dallas Watkins, Reporter for the Chicago Tribune. If Gaertner was the classiest murderess in Chicago, Beulah Annan was the prettiest. Gaertner attended the 1927 opening of Chicago in Chicago, Illinois. In 1926, Watkins went from reporter to Broadway playwright with Brave Little Women, a satirical stage play that would later be retitled Chicago. He is too slow." She based the two gun-toting protagonists—Roxie and Velma—on the real-life defendants Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner. Possibly due to the press coverage, and the fact that they were deemed “stylish” and “beautiful,” both Belva and Beulah, in their respective cases, were acquitted by the jury; Annan in May of 1924 and Gaertner a month later in June. Yup, he's just like poor Amos "Mr. Cellophane" Hart. (Read some for yourself!) Meet two of America’s first celebrity criminals: Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner. Prosecutors began to think you couldn't convict a pretty woman in this town. Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner didn’t meet until they both were put on ‘Murderesses Row’ in the Cook County Jail. Belva Gaertner (née Boosinger; September 14, 1884 – May 14, 1965) was a woman who was acquitted of murder in a 1924 trial. In response, both played on public sympathy to win their freedom. Beulah May Annan (née Sheriff; November 18, 1899 – March 10, 1928) was an American suspected murderer. Like Velma, Gaertner was a performer, specifically a cabaret singer who used the stage name Belle Brown. However, she soon tired of her mechanic husband and began taking up with a hot number named Harry Kalstedt. Once he was dead, Annan rang her husband to report she'd killed a man who'd tried to rape her. The two who are the focus of the play, Belva Gaertner and Beulah Annan clearly did the crimes. 281-955-3639 Heschel Feiner. Update your browser for more security and the best experience on this site. (Most of Hart's backstory was adapted from an unrelated murder case, that of Beulah Annan.) However, in their divorce papers, she later claimed he deserted her. The day after her acquittal, she told the press, "I have left my husband. So, she wrote about it. "Musical Theater and Law: Chicago, The Musical" by Geraldine Davila Gonzalez, April 30, 2019. At 23, Kentucky-native Annan was on her second marriage. Annan was a pretty young wife with a blue-collar husband. The show was well-received, running on Broadway for 172 performances and spurring a silent movie adaptation directed by lauded filmmaker Cecil B. DeMille. With tears and an expanding sob story, Annan claimed she was pregnant, and that was the source of her fatal fight with Kalstedt. Watkins wrote the series of articles in which she covered the two murder cases of Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner. 1924—Beulah Annan & Belva Gaertner Back to Notorious Chicago Chicago Tribune reporter Maurine Dallas Watkins (July 27, 1896 – August 10, 1969) covered these two murder cases in order to provide a “woman’s angle.” She left the Tribune after only six months and made millions on a play she wrote based on these two cases. The play is a satire and was based on two unrelated 1924 court cases involving two women, Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner, who were both suspected and later acquitted for murder, whom Watkins had covered for the Chicago Tribune as a reporter. It's said they set up a beauty school in the prison to help their sisters in stir look like captivating captives to the court and their all-male juries. ‎Show Once Upon A Crime | True Crime, Ep Stranger Than Fiction: Belva Gaertner & Beulah Annan and "Chicago" - Jul 13, 2020 Malin Akerman (“Billions”) plays Annan and Lake Bell (“Home Again”) plays Gaertner. Annan was 25 years old and married to her second husband when she was arrested in April 1924 for the murder of her lover and boss, Harry Kalstedt. Annan and Gaertner were rumored to have set up their own beauty shop out of their jail cell. She played it for four hours while drinking cocktails and waiting for her lover to breathe his last breath. While awaiting trial on 'Murderesses Row' in the Cook County Jail, Annan met Gaertner, who was also charged with killing a boyfriend. 45 thoughts we had while watching Basic Instinct, Countess Elizabeth Báthory and the dark truth behind her killer legend. Reportedly, this story sounded all the more compelling told with her "lovely soft Southern accent. The Chicago we know and love today is based on a 1926 play of the same name by reporter and dramatist Maurine Dallas Watkins. Following the trial she married William Gaertner and moved to Europe. The real story behind Chicago's Merry Murderesses, Roxie Hart and Velma Kelly, This Week in Genre History: Whoa! 281-237-3420 Ylwa Colletta. 281-237-8033 Bernadine Helander. "1924 - Beulah Annan & Belva Gaertner". That's not a coincidence. Still, Watkins worked in a juicy thread of skepticism in her columns about these alleged killers. The Definitive Ranking of Chicago's Hottest Criminals | UrbanMatter, 15+ Characters film fictitious and their prototypes in real life (Ursula is the most surprising) - Coolest Hacks, https://chicagology.com/notorious-chicago/beaulahandbelva/, Character Reasearch: Velma Kelly. Fangrrls is about kicking down doors, breaking boundaries and celebrating female fans with fun, witty and entertaining content. Music: "Hula Lou" - 1923 recording by Isabelle Patricola, Prosecutors would argue Annan had shot Kalstedt because he'd planned to end their affair, which she herself admitted to at one point. Beulah Annan (inspiration for Roxy Hart) Annan was found Not Guilty for the murder of Harry Kalstedt whom she claimed tried to make love to her. The play was adapted into a 1927 silent film, a 1975 stage musical, and a 2002 movie musical (which won the Academy Award for Best Picture), all with that title, and a 1942 romantic comedy film, Roxie Hart, named for the character who Annan inspired. True crime stories are all the rage these days, and this tale of accused murderesses in Prohibition-era Chicago is based on (unrelated) 1920s court cases involving Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner. Both were accused of murdering their lovers and both were acquitted. On March 11, 1924, Walter Law's corpse was found slumped over in the front seat of Gaertner's car. So, you see gentle public, she wasn't only shooting him in the back to save her own life but also the life of her unborn child! 281-955-0405 Panos Lanum. In fact, times haven't changed that much from Beulah Annan and Belva Gaertner up through O.J. One of two real life characters in the stage play "Chicago" (Velma Kelly in the play/movie), she was acquitted of murder in Chicago in 1924. Why should I have worried whether he loved me or whether he left me? Gaertner was a 38-year-old socialite with wealth and two to three divorces under her garter.